The research project on citizen participation in foreign and security policy, jointly led by Dr Hanna Pfeifer and Anna Geis (Helmut Schmidt University / University of the Federal Armed Forces Hamburg), has been successfully completed. Entitled “Recasting the Role of Citizens in Foreign and Security Policy? Democratic Innovations and Changing Patterns of Interaction between European Executives and Citizens”, the project was funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG) from 2022 to 2026.
The project investigated whether and how the role of citizens in foreign and security policy is changing – a policy field traditionally dominated by governments, diplomats and experts. It focused on new forms of dialogue and participation through which citizens are directly addressed and involved in political decision-making and deliberative processes concerning international, security-related and other transnational issues.
The findings show that democratic innovations in foreign and security policy remain comparatively rare. Nevertheless, our research in the four countries examined – Germany, France, Poland and the United Kingdom – found that governments have developed new formats for involving citizens in foreign and security policy, although these vary considerably across the four cases. At the same time, the specific characteristics of this policy field – including executive authority, international obligations and limited transparency – constrain the depth of citizen participation. Foreign policy elites are also reluctant to expose themselves to the political risks of open controversy. As a result, forms of citizen participation rarely amount to democratic innovations.
Conceptually, the project contributes to several strands of research: research on the role of public administration in democratic innovations; research on politicisation and public opinion in foreign and security policy; and research on how elites’ repertoires of engagement with citizens in this policy field are changing. The recasting of the role of citizens in foreign and security policy, together with the development of new formats for addressing and involving them in political decision-making processes, represents a remarkable development. It demonstrates that this policy field, too, has been affected by the deliberative and participatory wave of recent years.